Category Archives: French Wine

The League of Gentle Men at Restaurant Marseilles

League of Gentle Men at Restaurant Marseilles

 There was no theme for this meeting of the League of Gentle Men. Each member brought a wine that they particularly liked to share with the group. Unfortunately two of the wines this evening turned out to be corked.  

 As is our custom we begam with Champagne.  I was looking forward to this wine because I have not had the pleasure of drinking it before and 2002 was a great vintage in Champagne.

 2002 Pierre Gimmonet & Fils Champagne – Made from 100% Chardonnay grapes from the Cotes des Blances. This was a great way to start off the evening. The wine was drinking very well with nice fruit and a mineral character that put everyone in the right mood for the wine and food that was to follow.

 1993 Rene & Vincent Dauvissat “Les Clos” Chablis A great wine from the best of the grand cru vineyards and an outstanding producer. Classic Chablis and one of the best I have ever tasted!

 

1992 Batard-Montrachet Domaine Leflaive This is a great white wine from one of the best producers. It was rich and delicate at the same time with hints of butterscotch.

1989 Beaucastel–  Chateauneuf-du-Pape  One of our members loves this producer, but the wine was corked, a great disappointment.

Barolo 1983- Marchesi di Barolo 100% Nebbiolo. 1983 was a very good but not great vintage. The producer owns vineyards in the Barolo area but I am not sure if some of the grapes were purchased. The wine was drinking very well and it had all the classic aromas and flavors of an old Barolo, including tar, leather, and tea, without showing its age.

1987 Chateau Latour (Pauillac)  made from 75 % Cabernet, 20 Merlot and the rest Cabernet Franc and Petit Verdot, the blend depending on the vintage. I first began to drink Chateau Latour in 1968 with the 1963 vintage. 1963 was a very poor vintage in Bordeaux and the wine was selling in a wine store in Brooklyn for $3.99. For that price I bought a number of bottles and would drink them only with my then girlfriend, now wife, who was very impressed.  I still remember the aroma of the Latour when I opened the bottle. It wasn’t until later that I learned that Latour makes great wine even in off vintages. It has been my favorite Bordeaux ever since. It did not disappoint.

 1986 Mouton Rothschild (Pauillac) made from 85% Cabernet Sauvignon, 10% Cabernet Franc and 5% Merlot. 1986 was a very good year in Bordeaux and the wine was showing very well.

1982 Léoville Las Cases (St.Julien) Cabernet Sauvignon 65%, Merlot 17% Cabernet Blanc 13% and Petit Verdot 5%. This wine for me was the red wine of the evening, a great wine in a great year.

1996 Vega Sicilia Unico-Ribera del Duero made mostly from Tempranillo and Cabernet Sauvignon and produced only in good years and aged a minimum of 10 years before release.  This wine is aged in new French oak and new and used American oak for at least seven years and in bottle for about three years. This was a big wine but much too modern in style for my taste.

1953 Coteaux de Layon Moulin Touchais (Anjou) 100% Chenin Blanc This was one of the wines I was looking forward to tasting but it was corked, another disappointment.

1994 Savennieres – Roche Aux Moines, Domaine Aux Moines(Anjou) made from 100% Chenin Blanc. The soil is clay and shale. After pneumatic pressing fermentation takes place in stainless steel tanks, aging is stainless steel with a very limited use of new oak. This was a very interesting wine with a lot of flavor and fruit but with a dry finish.

Leave a comment

Filed under Barolo, Burgundy, Champagne, French Wine, Italian Red Wine

Sunday “Linner” with Friends

Sometimes we like to invite friends on a Sunday for a combination late lunch and early dinner.  We begin at 4PM so that we are able to take our time eating and drinking well into the night.  I don’t know why this type of meal hasn’t caught on the way brunch has.  Maybe it’s because “linner” sounds more like something from the dry cleaner than a meal. 

 The rule of thumb for wine service at any meal is one bottle of wine less than the number of guests, which I feel is the perfect fit.  Like all rules, this one is made to be broken and we often go to one bottle per person, not counting grappa, etc., depending on the guests. This time was no exception.  The food, the wine and the company could not have been better and we did eat and drink well into the night. There were six wines altogether and two very interesting “after dinner drinks” to end the meal.

 The Wines

 Billecart-Salmon Brut Reserve NV made from 40% Pinot Meunier, 30% Pinot Noir and 30% Chardonnay from three different years and the majority of the base wine is from the 2005 vintage. It had full fruit, clean with hints of citrus, flowers and slight mineral character.

 Ferrari Centanni 1902/2002- Millesimo 1995-Sboccatura 2002 Method Classico(Trento) The winery was founded in 1902 by Giulio Farrari. The wine is from the 1995 vintage and it was released in 2002. This bottle is, I believe, a replica of the one used in 1902.

The “punt” is not a push up but a push down so the bottle cannot stand and has to be on its side. This was a big rich and toasty wine with a great finish and aftertaste.

 Meursault-Charmes Premier Cru-Domaine Potinet Ampeau 1969 100% Chardonnay

There was some doubt that this wine might not show well but it did. It was showing its age but still had all the aromas and flavors of a wonderful white Burgundy.

 Chateau Musar 1998– Lebanon-after fermentation, maceration is for 2/4 weeks and the wine is aged in Bordeaux type barrels of Nevers oak for 12/15months. At the end of the second year blending takes place with the proportions of Cabernet Sauvignon, Carignan and Cinsault varying with each vintage, the only deciding factor being taste. It is blended in the third year before being bottled and is aged in the cellar for 3/4 years. The wine is released after seven years. The grapes are grown in gravely soil with a limestone base in the Bekaa Valley. The grapes are hand picked. The wine is not fined or filtered and there are no chemical additives with the exception of the minimum dose of sulfur.

 Barbaresco “Pora” 1978 Produttori del Barbaresco 100 % Nebbiolo

The clay soil is rich in limestone with sandy veins. The Pora vineyard is at 300 meters with a south to south east exposure. The grapes are handpicked and placed into small baskets. Fermentation is in stainless steel vats for 2/3 weeks. Maceration is 18/20 days and then the wine is aged for 36 months in 20/50 hl oak barrels. It remains in bottle for another 8 months before it is released. 1978 was a great year in Barbaresco. This is classic Barbaresco, more rustic than elegant with hints of cherry, leather, tea and spice. It was drinking very well. This is one of the oldest cooperatives in Italy and it may be the best.  The name of the grape growers is written on the back label.

 Gevrey-Chambertin Clos Saint-Jacques 1969 Remoissenet Pere & Fils 100% Pinot Noir.

This was classic red Burgundy at its best, very mellow and not showing its age.

 The red wines were complemented perfectly by the Lamb Shanks Osso Buco Style that Michele had prepared in the slow cooker. 

 Armagnac Vaghi 1942

The year 1942 was not a good year for wine or for the world as it was the middle of WWII. However it was a great year for Armagnac. This was the last bottle and I doubt if I will be buying any more as the price has gone over $600 a bottle.

 There was only a little of the Armagnac left so I brought out my last bottle of Levi Grappa. The last bottle for two reasons, it is the last bottle that I have and it was one of the last made by the “Angel of Grappa”, Romano Levi, before he died a few years ago.

2 Comments

Filed under Barbaresco, Burgundy, Champagne, French Wine, Italian Red Wine, Italian Wine, White wine

An Evening with Domaine Joseph Drouhin at Bar Boulud

 

Our friend Tony Di Dio of Tony Di Dio Selections occasionally hosts wine dinners at some of the city’s best restaurants.  One in particular caught Michele’s eye:  an evening with Laurent Drouhin of France’s Drouhin Winery at Bar Boulud for an all inclusive price of $129.  Since Michele is a big fan of both Burgundy wine and French food, we decided to go. 

 At the restaurant, we were directed to the private dining room next to the wine cellar.

We sat with Laurent Drouhin so I was able to ask him many questions. His English is perfect as he has lived in Westchester for a number of years.

Laurent Drouhin

 Laurent spoke about the terroir, how important it is to them and how all of his family’s wines are terroir driven. He said that every effort is made to respect the terroir in all its diversity and that they are able to express the exact character of each terroir by using an organic and biodynamic approach. The soil is very important and they respect and ensure the quality by plowing by horse, allowing grass to grow between the vines and using natural compost and natural predators.  The root stock is grown in their own nursery in order to preserve the genetic heritage and control the quality.

 He was very proud of the fact that they basically make wine as his great-grandfather did, using as little interference in the natural processes as possible and making sure that technical knowhow is always at the service of authenticity.

 Laurent said that because 2009 was a great year, many people that visit the winery or want to taste the wines are only interested in the 2009. He said that 2008 was a very good vintage and that people should give it a chance.

The Wines

 Chablis 2009 Domaine de Vaudon 100% Chardonnay  The vineyards are located in the northern- most region of Burgundy in a dramatic circle of hills where vines have been planted for hundreds of years. The soil is Kimmerdgian limestone and contains millions of tiny marine fossils embedded in a kind of whitish mortar which may have been the bottom of a sea. This marine origin is the reason for the unique character of the wines of Chablis.

There are 6,250 vines/ht and double Guyot called the“Vallee la Marme” (long canes on a short permanent trunk) for its resistance to frost. The grapes and must are purchased from regular suppliers with long term contracts, as is all the purchased wine and must. Very slow pressing takes place to protect the fruit and the wine is placed in aging vats for 7/8 months. It has a floral style, with a mineral character and hints of citrus.  Laurent said that starting with the 2008 vintage the name Vaudon will be associated with all of their Chablis wines as a sign of their allegiance to the historic terroir. $21

 Puligny Montrachet 2008 100% Chardonnay The vineyard is located in the middle part of the Cote de Beaune and there are 10,000 vines/ht. The system is Guyot and the yield is 51hl/ha less than the law allows. Very slow pressing to respect the fruit and no yeast or enzymes are added. The wine goes directly into barrels after the “debourbage” and the wine is decanted to reduce the sediment. It is aged in French oak barrels of which 25% are new for 12 months. It is a soft, smooth, elegant wine with hints of white peach and honey and a nice finish and after taste. $54

 Beaune 1er Cru – Clos des Mouches Blanc 2008 100% Chardonnay The vineyard is at Southern end of the Beaune appellation next to Pommard. It is at the middle slope, on a mild incline with an east/southeast exposure. It is 35 acres (14 hectares) making it the largest parcel in the Clos des Mouches. Laurent said that it is rocky soil of clay and limestone in the upper part of the vineyard. In the center there is limestone and marl. He went on to say that this light composition is responsible for the finesse of the wine. He said that there is 10,000/12500 plants/ha in order to extract all the possible nuances from the terroir and limit the production of each vine. In was very proud of the fact that they keep their yields low- 20% less than allowed by law. Harvesting is by hand and the grapes are sorted twice, when being picked and again on the sorting table at the winery.

In 2008 malolatic fermentation began later than usual and lasted several months. He felt that the aging on the lees allowed the wine to gain complexity, remain fresh and reduced the acidity level.  The wine is aged in “French forest oak” barriques for 12/16 months, 25% are new oak.

They insist that the weathering of the wood take place for three years. Laurent said that this was one of the controlling elements in the elegance of the wine.

I really liked this wine. It was well balanced, complex with a rich texture. There were floral aromas, hints of honey, fruit and almonds with a mineral, earthy feel running through the middle palate. $102.000                                                                      

 Savigny-les-Beaune 1er Cru-Serpentieres 2006 100% Pinot Noir Savigny is a village in a small valley north of Beaune. Les Serpentieres is a vineyard that faces due south.   The soil is marl and limestone from the Bathonian age; it is a light soil with reddish coloration, strewn with sharp stones. 10,000 plants/ha and the system is Guyot. The grapes and the wine are provided by regular supply partners with long term contract.                        Maceration and vinification is 2/3 weeks temperature controlled with the use of indigenous yeast. Punching down of the cap (pigeage) is done once a day until one half of the fermentation is complete, then pumping over (remontage) once a day until the fermentation is complete.  Pressing takes place in a vertical press and there is the separation of the free run juice from the pressed juice. The wine is aged in French oak of which 10% is new for 12/15 months. There is a velvety texture to the wine, very delicate with good fruit flavors and hints of spice and pepper. $41 

Beaune 1er Cru-Clos des Mouches Rouge 2008 100% Pinot Noir $91 the average age of the vines is 39 years. The vineyard is 6.75 hectares and the system is Guyot. The wine is aged in French oak mostly Troncay for 14/18 months. 20% of the oak is new. $91

 Chambolle-Musigny 1er Cru 2008 100% Pinot Noir which is at the heart of the famous Chambolle- Musigny vineyard with an eastern exposure. Average age of the wines is 32 years. The limestone sub soil is of Jurassic age origin and Laurent said it was ideally suited for Pinot Noir. The vineyard is 1.3 ha. It is aged in French oak of which 20% is new for 14/18 months. The wine made one think of little red berries with hints of black cherry and an earthy quality with a long finish and nice aftertaste. $87

 Nuits-Saint –Georges 2005 100% Pinot Noir $61 Laurent pointed out that 2005 was an excellent year. The appellation is colongated, with two different sections the north and the south separated by a little stream that crosses the town. The hillside is quite steep and the vineyards have an eastern exposure. The soil has outcroppings of hard chalk in many places; Laurent said that the northern part of the Nuits, close to Vosne produces wines of great finesse, the southern part, with its rockier soil gives powerful and long lasting wines. There are 10,000 vines per hectar, the Guyot system and the yield of 45hl/ha. The grapes and must were supplied by their regular sources.

Maceration and vinification is for 2/3 weeks and the wine is aged in French oak which 20% is new for 14/18 months. There was good balance between acidity, alcohol and the tannins. It is this balance Laurent pointed out which gives the wine its elegance. There were hints of cherry and blackberry. The wine was very well structured yet with a certain softness and elegance.

 As a wise man once said there is Pinot Noir and then there is Burgundy!

Leave a comment

Filed under Burgundy, Drouhin, French Wine

The Return of the League of Gentle Men at Nizza

The League of Gentle Men* at Nizza

Since 2011 marks the 150th anniversary of Italian unification, some of our members felt that our tasting should feature Italian wines, but others wanted French. We decided to do both and call it the Italian-French connection. The restaurant we went to was Nizza, which is the Italian name for the city of Nice.  Before 1860, Nice and the surrounding area belonged to the House of Savoy in Piemonte. It was given to France to stop them from interfering in the unification of Italy.

 I have eaten at Nizza a number of times and am always impressed with the food. The shrimp scampi is excellent and the pizza and salads are very good. Two main courses that I really enjoy there are the Porchetta and the Branzino fillet. The restaurant also serves an excellent thin pie made with chickpea flour that really reminds me of Nice. The French call it socca and the Italians call it farinata. 

 With our meal, we enjoyed wines from Provence, the Rhone, Piedmont and Rome.

No matter what the theme, we always start with Champagne, this time it was the Salon Vintage Blanc de Blancs 1997 and it got us off to a great start.

  Chateau D’Arlay 2002 Cotes du Jura made from 100% Pinot Noir from old vines. The wine is matured in oak barrels for three years. This was a light wine and it worked very well as the first red wine.

 Domain Juliette Avril 2000 Chateauneuf-du-Pape 2000 made from Grenache, Syrah and Mourvedre. Grapes are handpicked between Sept 10 and 15, traditional vinification with partial stripping. Temperature controlled fermentation in 100hl stainless steel tanks for at least 12 days. 10% of the harvest is transferred to barrels. This wine needed more time.

 Chateau Vignelaure 1985 Coteaux d’ Aix-en- Provence. It is 60% Cabernet Sauvignon, 25% Grenache and 15% Syrah. Soil composition is limestone, clay and gravel. 1985 was a very good year. Part of the fruit was not destemmed and the wine was aged in French oak, 8,500 liters, and the equivalent of 38 barrels. This was a wine that had matured very nicely, with soft tannins, nice fruit with hints of blackberry and cherry.

 Today the wine is aged in small oak barrels (one third new) 75% French and 25% American oak, for 18 months and two years in bottle before release. I have not tasted recent vintages from this producer so I cannot comment on their new methods.

 Fiorano Rosso 1994 Boncompagni Ludovisi Principe di Venosa Lazio Cabernet Sauvignon and Merlot. The wine is aged for two years in big barrels of Slovenian oak.

This wine is not made any more; the last vintage was the 1995. I have been lucky enough to have had many vintages of this wine going back to 1961 and I had a 1967 last year. The wine never disappoints and I have never had a bad bottle. The wine can age so I opened the bottle about one hour before I was to leave for the dinner. When I arrived at Nizza the wine was decanted and it was another hour before we were ready to drink it. The combination of leather, cherry and a touch of tobacco makes it unlike any wine I have ever tasted except maybe a very traditional old Bordeaux. The wine was just opening up after about an hour in the glass.

  Hermitage “La Chapelle” 1986 Paul Jaboulet Anie Rhone  100% Syrah The grapes are not from a single vineyard but are blended from the divers terroir of Les Bessards, Les Greffeux, Le Meal and Les Rocoules. The grapes are handpicked and each parcel is vinified separately. It is aged between 15 and 18 months in the cellar. The different parcels are blended and it receives additional time in barrel and bottle before release. It was drinking very well, not showing any age with hints of black fruit, red currants, spice and a touch of leather.

 1989 Mas des Daumas Gassac 1989 Languedoc made from 70% Cabernet Sauvignon and 30% Malbec, Merlot, Syrah Cabernet Franc, Pinot and Tanit. This is a big dark wine with dark fruit aromas and flavors and a hint of spice and leather.

 1978 Bricco Bussia Aldo Conterno 100% Nebbiolo sub-varieties Michet and Lampia.This is a great, classic Barolo with hints of faded roses, leather, tar and tea.

 *The League of Gentle Men is a group of gentlemen who meet once a month or so to drink great wine, eat good food, and enjoy each other’s company.

Leave a comment

Filed under Barolo, French Wine

Tasting Domaine de Chevalier and Chateau Haut-Bailly

Wine Media Guild Tasting and Lunch at Felidia Restaurant with Olivier Bernard, owner of Domaine de Chevalier and Cellar Master Gabriel Vialard and owner Robert Wilmers of Chateau Haut-Bailly

 I had just finished tasting all of the wine and was standing with a few other members of the Wine Media Guild when Olivier Bernard, the owner of Domaine de Chevalier stopped to join us. He is a very personable, charming man with a great sense of humor. We spoke about the differences in the wine and food when you move from one area of France to another and how the people in the area around Paris, the coast and the interior all have very different attitudes.

Domaine de Chevalier and Oliver Bernard

Later when he was speaking about wine, he caught my attention when he said that he had great respect for the terroir. Wine must be an expression of the soil and the wine maker must always keep this in mind. He went on to say that concentration in wine making is natural but extraction is human interference. It is easy to make big wine but difficult to make fine wine.

 At the lunch that followed I was sitting next to Gabriel Vialard the Cellar Master for Ch. Haut-Bailly.  Mr. Vialard said that both properties are very close to each other but I could taste a difference in the wines. He said that part of the reason for this was the soil. At Domaine de Chevalier it is manily gravelly black sand, a subsoil of clay and gravel mixed with iron rich sandstone. At Haut-Bailly the makeup of the soil is different. There is a mosaic of soils, the best being a compact clay-based subsoil with gravel on top.

Chateau Haut- Bailly

 He also made it clear that they only make red wine. Of the vines planted 64% is cabernet sauvignon, 30% merlot and 6% Cabernet Franc.  What was unique was a 100 year old parcel of mixed vines: malbec, carmenere, and petit verdot and it represented 20% of the blend each year.

 We tasted three whites from Domaine de Chevalier: 2007, 2005 and 2001. They all had a very pleasant grass aroma and flavors with a mineral quality and, good acidity .The 2001 was still very fresh and also complex.

 Oliver Bernard said that his winery produced white wine made from 70% sauvignon blanc and 30% semillon. There is a very careful selection process in the vineyard, the juice is cold settled and fermented in oak barrels, 35 % of which are new. The wine spends 18 months in barrel, longer than any other dry white in Bordeaux.

 The reds are made from 64% cabernet sauvignon, 30% merlot, 3% cabernet franc and 3% petit verdot.

 We tasted the red wine side by side from 2007-2000.I asked Mr.Vialard about the vintages. He said that the 2001, 2004 and 2006 would last a long time. The 2005 is one of those great vintages that do not come along often. 2002 was a good value and 2003 lacked acidity; both were good buys but would not age well. 2000 was a wine with good tannin and 2007 was a light vintage and he put more cabernet sauvignon than usual in the blend. This wine would be bought by the restaurants in France because it will be ready to drink sooner.  He also believed that Americans made too much of the idea of “vintage”.

 With lunch we had the 1990 Domaine de Chevalier which was a perfect match with the main course. Some of the members of the Wine Media Guild were kind enough to bring older bottles of Domaine de Chevalier. I was able to taste the 1985 and the 1982 which proved to me the wines can age. The 1979 seemed a bit vegetative but I only had a small taste.

 The main difference in the wines was that the Domaine de Chevalier seemed more fruit forward with softer tannins. The Haut-Bailly seemed to be less forward, tighter and more tannic. When I mentioned this to Mr. Vialard he said he agreed, and then if I understood him correctly, he said that 15 years ago it would have been the reverse! 

 There was also a discussion by the speakers dealing with the Bordeaux market in this country. The biggest importer of Bordeaux in the United States has stopped bringing in the wine. They are trying to get rid of their inventory by “dumping” the wine (selling it for less). The speakers agreed that this was a problem but no one seemed to know if this would lower the price of Bordeaux  to the consumer.

4 Comments

Filed under French Wine

The League of Gentle Men Drink French Wine

The League of Gentle Men had its last official wine dinner of the year at Gramercy Tavern.  We decided to do French wines: Champagne, Burgundy, and Bordeaux .Michael Anthony, the executive chef, matched each wine with a different course. There were six members at the dinner.

 We started as we always do with champagne. This time it was the Dom Perignon 1996 Rose’. 1996 was a great year for Champagne and this wine proved it. There were aromas of pink grapefruit and pomegranate and it was fresh and fruity. The second champagne was Krug 1982, also a great year for champagne.  

The Wines

One of our members always brings Krug. The 1982 was elegant with good fruit but still had that Krug structure and body. It was a great food wine. These were two of the best champagnes I had last year!

 White Wines

 Meursault Clos de la Barre 1994- Domaine des Comtes Lafon (Cote de Beaune)-This wine was a complete surprise for me. It is difficult to explain because to me it tasted so good that it would be very difficult to put it in words. I just sat back and enjoyed it.

 Puligny-Montrachet  Les Combettes 1986 – Robert Ampeau (Cote de Beaune). It was showing very well with great flavors and aromas.

Red Wines

 Bonnes Mares 1969- Leroy (Cote de Nuits)-This is the third time that I have been lucky enough to taste this wine in the last three months. It is everything a great Burgundy should be.

 Richebourg 1972- Domaine de la Romanee Conti (Cote de Nuits)–it was showing its age a bit but still a great wine in what some might say was not a great year.

 Ausone (magnum) 1988 (Saint Emilion) 50% Merlot and 50% Cabernet Franc–I believe that it is one of the few red wines that do not undergo malalactic fermentation. It could not have been better.

One of our members always brings a dessert wine but does not tell us in advance the name of the wine or the producer. He always waits until we are finished with all the other wines before he brings it out .I believed that I had copied down the name. The wine was a 76er(year) from Germany, but when I tried to look up the name on-line, I kept on getting the German phone book white pages. No one seems to remember the name, but it was very good and I will try to find the name of the producer. The wine was a 76er BA Weingut Gernot Gysher- next time I will write down the names of all the wines before I begin to drink

4 Comments

Filed under French Wine

League of Gentle Men:Burgundy, Champagne and Bordeaux

The League of Gentle Men

The day before our latest dinner, one of the members asked if I could come before our meeting to taste a bottle of wine. It was an older vintage and he wanted to try a bottle before investing in a whole case. He had visited the producer and had a special fondness for his wines.

1969 Bonnes Mares Domaine LeRoy

1969 Bonnes Mares Domaine LeRoy

I arrived early and sitting on the table was a bottle of 1969 Bonnes Mares from Domaine Leroy. The bottle came from a case that had been recently opened.  It appeared to be pristine and the fill was very good. The cork was also in very good condition and was removed with an Ah-so opener. The color of the wine did not give away its age; it looked like a much younger than its years. The bouquet and taste did not reveal any signs of age and it had all the aromas and flavors of a great Burgundy.  I thought it was one of the best Burgundies that I have ever tasted, or should I say drank. Since the wines we were having with our dinner were a horizontal of Cos d’ Estournel, we debated for a few minutes whether we should finish the bottle with so many good wines to come.  But before we knew it, the whole bottle of the 1969 Burgundy was gone. I advised my host to buy the rest of the case.

Magnum of 1989 Krug

Magnum of 1989 Krug

We have a tradition of starting off our dinners with Champagne, usually Krug, and this night was no exception. We began with 1989 Krug in magnum. At our last meeting in July we had a 1990 Krug also from a magnum. There was a vast difference between the two. The 1990 was fresh and bright and could last for many more years. The 1989 was very toasty and tasted like a much older wine and should be drunk now.

There were 7 of us at the dinner and we had eight bottles of Cos d’ Estournel (St.-Estephe) 55-60% Cabernet Sauvignon,35-40% Merlot with some Cabernet Franc.

 The vintages were 1966, 1975 1978, 1982, 1985, 1986, 1988 and 1990.

Clos d'Estournel

Clos d'Estournel

We decided to start with the oldest wines first to give the young ones time to open up.

All the wines showed very well and none of them were displayed any signs of age.

It is interesting to go back and read some of the comments written about this wine in 1966. The opinion seemed to be that the wine would not last into the 1990’s but here it was 2009 and the wine was still in great condition. 1975 was a vintage that most believed would never really mature because there was so much tannin that it would out last the fruit. The wine has matured very well. The tannins have mellowed and the fruit was still there.  It was the surprise of the evening.  82’s were given very high marks but the 1978, 1985, and 1988 were drinking much better. It was not that the 1982 was not good, it was just not as good as the others. I had the 1990 two weeks ago and it is a big wine with a lot of tannin and fruit and needs much more time. The 1990 we had this night did not change my opinion. There was also a 1996 but because the 1990 was not ready to drink we saved the 1996 for another time.

Once again it shows how long great Bordeaux can age and that sometimes the vintages that get all the hype are not the best in the long run.

 Michele and I are teaching at De Gustibus at Macy’s on Thursday Dec 3, 2009 For information & tickets 212-239-1652, www.degustibusnyc.com      Italian food&wine

Leave a comment

Filed under French Wine

The League of Gentle Men Celebrate Bastille Day

My men’s wine group “The League of Gentle Men” decided to have a dinner to celebrate Bastille Day. We could not do it on July 14th so we celebrated to the 13th. It was held at Nice-Martin on the upper West Side. The food was excellent and went well with the wine. The theme of course would be French. For the first time we invited women. Only one of them showed up stayed for the champagne, and left.

The wines

The wines

 We started as we always do with Krug. This was a special treat because it was a magnum of the 1990.It did not taste like it was almost 20 years old. It was fresh and alive and has many long years ahead of it. I would have guessed it as being a 1998.It is always better to drink Champagne from a magnum

Next was one of my favorite white wines the 1996 Chablis Premier Cru Vaillons from Domain Jean and Sebastien Dauvissat. It had citrus aromas, hints of lemon and pear with a good mineral character and acidity, a great finish and after taste. This is an understated, balanced and elegant wine. It was served almost at room temperature which enhanced the flavor.

Chateau Lanessan 1996Haut Medoc-75% Cabernet Sauvignon, 20% Merlot 4% Piet Verdot & 1% Cabernet Franc. The blend is dominated by Cabernet Sauvignon but it did not show in the wine. It was a very balanced wine, easy to drink, with red fruit aromas and flavors and a pleasant finish and aftertaste.

 Chateau Haut- Bages 1990 Averous-Pauillac There must be a lot of Cabernet Sauvignon in the wine because it had very pronounced bell-pepper flavors and aromas, which I found, made it a little one dimensional. It is the second label of Chateau Lynch Bages

 1989 Chateau L’Evangile- Pomerol  Made from 78 % Merlot and 22 % Cabernet Franc  This was a very concentrated wine with berry aromas of raspberry and cassis, and flavors of blackberries with a mineral character.

 1962 Chateau Lafite Rothchild-Pauillac- It was very interesting that the wine needed a few minutes in the glass to open up. It was ready to drink but could last for a few more years.

1979 Château Latour-Paullic This has always been my favorite Bordeaux and it was in my opinion the wine of the evening, classic Bordeaux in every sense of the word.

 1990 Chateau MontrosSaint Esteph– after we drank the wine some one said they believed the Wine Spectator gave it a rating of 100. It was a classic wine with red fruit aromas and flavors.

 1983 Mas De Daumas Grassac- Languedoc- This is a very interesting wine and one that most of our members were not familiar with. It is made from 80% Cabernet Sauvignon and the other 20% made up of a number of grapes including: Malbec, Cabernet Franc, Syrah, and Tannat among others. It had aromas of black fruit including black berries and black currents with a leathery berry flavor which continued in the finish and after taste. It was like an “old style” Bordeaux and had more than a few years left and the color was still dark.

 1988 Chateau Lafaurie- Peyraguey– I have never had a sauternes from this producer. One of our members  always brings an interesting dessert. It was the perfect way to end a great evening, sipping the wine and enjoying its orange marmalade flavor with over tones of honey and floral herbs, hints of spice, good acidity and mineral character.

The perfect ending

The perfect ending

Leave a comment

Filed under French Wine

The League of Gentle Men-Burgundy and Champagne at Bouley

The League of Gentle Men – Burgundy and Champagne at Bouley

 

   Someone said “Burgundy”, someone else said “Burgundy is always good”, and it was settled.

One member suggested Bouley, adding that he could make arrangements so that we could bring our own wine.

All agreed.  There are eight of us and the rule is one bottle per person – the rule is always broken.

   We started with Champagne — The 2000 Cristal Brut – 55 % Pinot Noir & 45% Chardonnay – it was rich, round, fruity and very elegant. I felt it was just coming into its own. Next was the 1995 Salon Le Mesnil – Blanc de Blanc. It was full bodied and complex with hints of nuts and coffee. This wine could last for many more years.

The Champagne

The Champagne

  1989 Bienvenues Batard Montrachet- Domaine Leflaive. This wine had everything going for it. Rich, round, complex, with aromas and flavors of honeysuckle and a steel minerality running right through the middle. The finish was long and lush and the aftertaste went on and on. This wine could last for 10 more years at least.

  2000 Red Meursault (Mangum) – Alain Cuche Bizouard. The wine was very light in color and light on the palate. It has all the burgundy characteristics but they were very subtle.

 

1998 Bouchard Pere & Fils Grand Vin De Beaune Greves Vigne de L’Enfant Jesus. Good combination of fruit and spice, with aromas of dark cherry and raspberry and a nice finish and aftertaste. It has many years to go.  

1990 Richotes Chambertin Monopole – Armand Rorisseau– soft red fruit flavors and a surprising youthfulness for a wine almost 20 years old.

1988 Echezeaux –  Henri Jayer – flavors and aromas of black raspberries, plum, coffee and mineral characteristics. The finish was long and complex.

1972 Clos de la Roche Joseph Drouhin. This was the red wine of the evening. It had everything one would want in an older Burgundy.

Some of the Wine

Some of the Wine

We ended with 2 bottles of Tokaji from Arvay – the first was an “Asuz” 2000 with it was six puttonys and the other said “sweet” 2001 and may have been late harvest. They both had fruity aromas and flavors with a lot of apricot and a finish and after taste like liquid silk. I could not taste much difference between them but at that point in the evening……. There were 15 wines in all but some were corked and some were just not up to par, which is why some members insist on bringing more than one bottle. And as one member is fond of saying “ There is Pinot Noir and then there is Burgundy”!

Three of the Wines

Three of the Wines

Leave a comment

Filed under French Wine